Yours or Mine? Distributing the Wedding Gifts in Divorce

What are the Guidelines to Divide Wedding Gifts in a Divorce Scenario in New Jersey?

Yours or Mine? Distributing the Wedding Gifts in Divorce in NJGetting married and starting a new life with your favorite person is a wonderful thing. The event is usually celebrated with gifts from loved ones. But if “happily ever after” doesn’t work out for you, you need to know some important legal aspects of property division—and it would be wise to consult a smart attorney like the ones at Montanari Law Group. You might think the best solution is for you to take the gifts given to you by the guests you invited and your spouse to take the gifts given by his or her guests. This would work, but only if the two of you agree to it. In reality, you both are entitled to lay claim to any of the gifts. In New Jersey, the doctrine that applies to dividing up property, which includes wedding gifts, is that of equitable distribution. This doctrine says that all assets acquired during the marriage must be split equitably, though this might not necessarily mean equally.

How Wedding Gifts are Fairly Distributed in NJ Divorces

Unlike some other states that follow community property principles, New Jersey follows the principle of equitable distribution. Under the doctrine of equitable distribution, the court considers various factors to determine how to divide marital assets and debts. These factors may include the length of the marriage, as longer marriages may warrant a more balanced distribution. The court also considers the income and earning potential of each spouse when determining the division of assets. The spouses’ age and health are considered to assess their respective needs and financial situations.

Another factor the court evaluates is the contributions of each spouse during the marriage, including financial contributions, homemaking, child-rearing, and support for the other spouse’s career or education. The court considers the standard of living established during the marriage and aims to maintain a similar standard for both spouses after divorce, to the extent possible. The court also takes into account the debts and liabilities incurred during the marriage and may allocate them between the spouses.

It’s important to note that equitable distribution typically applies only to marital property, which generally includes assets acquired during the marriage, regardless of who owns the property or whose name is on the title. Separate property, such as assets acquired before the marriage or through inheritance or gifts, is generally excluded from equitable distribution.

Examining Alternative Viewpoints on How to Divide Wedding Gifts

In the context of divorce or separation, there are generally four perspectives or approaches that can be considered. These perspectives represent different ways of approaching the division of wedding gifts:

Community Property Perspective

In states that follow community property laws, such as California, Arizona, or Texas, wedding gifts are typically considered community property. According to this perspective, all assets acquired during the marriage, including wedding gifts, are equally owned by both spouses and subject to a 50/50 division upon divorce.

Separate Property Perspective

Under the separate property perspective, wedding gifts are viewed as the separate property of the spouse who received the gift. This perspective asserts that gifts received by an individual spouse belong exclusively to that spouse and are not subject to division during divorce.

Proportional Contribution Perspective

This perspective takes into account the contributions of each spouse to the marriage and applies a proportional approach. It considers factors such as financial contributions, homemaking, child-rearing, and support for the other spouse’s career. Wedding gifts may be divided based on the proportional contribution of each spouse to the marriage.

Equitable Distribution Perspective

The equitable distribution perspective, followed in New Jersey, seeks to distribute marital assets, including wedding gifts, in a manner that is fair and just but not necessarily equal. As we mentioned, this approach considers various factors such as the length of the marriage, income, and earning capacity of each spouse, contributions to the marriage, and the standard of living established during the marriage.

Governing Standards for the Classification of Wedding Presents as Marital Assets

In New Jersey, the classification of wedding gifts as marital assets depends on several factors. While the general rule is that gifts received by either spouse during the marriage are considered marital property subject to equitable distribution, there are certain exceptions and circumstances that may impact their classification. Following are some criteria that can help determine the classification of wedding gifts in New Jersey.

The intention of the person giving the gift is a significant factor. If the donor explicitly intended the gift to be for both spouses or for the couple as a unit, it is more likely to be classified as a marital asset. If there was an express agreement between the spouses regarding the gift, such as an agreement that all gifts received during the marriage would be joint property, it can impact the classification.

If the gifted property was commingled with marital assets, such as depositing cash into a joint bank account or using the gift to purchase joint property, it may be treated as marital property. If the gift was primarily used and enjoyed by both spouses during the marriage, it may be considered a marital asset. The court may consider the contributions of each spouse towards the acquisition or maintenance of the gift. If one spouse played a significant role in obtaining or preserving the gift, it might impact the classification. The presence of documentation, such as gift cards or letters, specifying the recipient as both spouses, can support the argument that the gift is marital property.

Please note that each case is unique, and the court will consider the specific circumstances and evidence presented. If there is a dispute regarding the classification of wedding gifts, it is advisable to consult with a family law attorney in New Jersey, like those at The Montanari Law Group, who can provide guidance based on the details of your situation and applicable laws.

What if a Person Receives a Personal Gift on the Wedding Day?

How to Divide Wedding Gifts in a Divorce Context in New JerseyIn that scenario, it is generally considered the recipient’s separate property rather than a marital asset in New Jersey. Separate property refers to assets that are owned by one spouse individually and are not subject to equitable distribution during a divorce.

In the context of wedding gifts, if a gift is intended solely for one spouse and not for both spouses or the couple as a unit, it is typically considered the separate property of the recipient spouse. This could include gifts given by family members, friends, or individuals who specifically intended the gift for one spouse.

However, it’s important to note that the classification of assets can sometimes be complex, and there may be circumstances where the nature of the gift or the intentions of the parties involved could lead to a different determination.

Recommendations for Handling the Separation of Wedding Gifts

Separating wedding gifts can be a sensitive and potentially challenging task during a divorce or separation. To help navigate this process, it’s important to have open and respectful communication with your spouse about the division of wedding gifts. Discuss your expectations, concerns, and preferences regarding the gifts in a calm and constructive manner.

We recommend that you create a detailed inventory of all wedding gifts received. Note the description of each gift, the giver (if known), and any accompanying documentation such as gift cards or letters. This inventory will help ensure transparency and assist in the decision-making process. Some gifts may have significant sentimental value to one or both spouses. Take this into account when discussing the division. If certain items hold particular meaning for one spouse, it may be appropriate for that person to retain those items.

It’s important to evaluate whether any gifts were explicitly intended for one spouse or were received as personal gifts. Separate these items from the marital assets and clarify their ownership as the separate property of the recipient spouse. If you and your spouse are having difficulty reaching an agreement on the division of gifts, consider utilizing mediation or negotiation techniques. A neutral third party, such as a mediator or collaborative divorce professional, can help facilitate productive discussions and find mutually acceptable solutions.

It is advised that once you and your spouse reach an agreement on the division of wedding gifts, document the agreement in writing. This can help prevent future disputes or misunderstandings.

An Experienced Attorney Can Assist with Separating Wedding Gifts during Your Divorce

An attorney can play a crucial role in assisting you with the separation of wedding gifts during a divorce or separation. A family law attorney has a deep understanding of the relevant laws and regulations governing the division of assets, including wedding gifts, in your jurisdiction. They can explain how the law applies to your specific situation and help you navigate any legal complexities.

An attorney can also carefully analyze the nature of each gift and determine whether it qualifies as marital property or separate property. They can assess factors such as the intention of the giver, agreements between spouses, and the circumstances of the gift’s acquisition to establish its proper classification. In New Jersey, which follows equitable distribution principles, an attorney can provide guidance on the factors considered by the court in dividing marital assets. They can help you understand how wedding gifts may be factored into the overall equitable distribution scheme and advocate for a fair and favorable outcome.

An attorney can also act as your advocate during negotiations with your spouse or their attorney. They can help you articulate your needs and interests regarding the division of wedding gifts and work towards a mutually acceptable settlement. Their negotiation skills can be valuable in protecting your rights and achieving a favorable outcome. In cases where disputes arise over the separation of wedding gifts, an attorney can represent you in mediation or alternative dispute resolution processes. They can help facilitate discussions, present your case effectively, and work towards a resolution that is fair and reasonable.

In the event the division of wedding gifts becomes contentious and requires court intervention, an attorney can represent you in litigation. They can gather evidence, present arguments, and advocate for your position in court to protect your interests and pursue a favorable outcome. An attorney can also assist with the preparation and review of legal documents related to the division of wedding gifts, such as settlement agreements or court filings. They can ensure that all necessary legal formalities are followed and help protect your rights and interests throughout the process.

Count on a Trusted Divorce Lawyer to Handle Division of Your Wedding Presents in Ridgewood, Montvale, Franklin Lakes, Wyckoff, and throughout New Jersey

Dividing up property in a divorce usually gets emotional and often contentious between two people who are separating, especially when sentimental things, like wedding gifts, are involved. Each divorce case is unique, and the court exercises discretion in determining the division of assets based on the specific circumstances involved.  At The Montanari Law Group, our attorneys’ experience and legal guidance can provide you with valuable support, ensuring that the separation of wedding gifts is handled in a fair and legally sound manner during your divorce or separation proceedings.

Consult with our team of family lawyers for advice tailored to your particular situation in Montvale, Caldwell, Haledon, Paramus, Wyckoff, Totowa, Montclair, Millburn, Hawthorne, and throughout Passaic County, Bergen County, Essex County, and surrounding areas in New Jersey. If you are considering a divorce and are unsure of how to handle equitable distribution issues, call (973) 233-4396 or use our online form to schedule your free consultation. Our attorneys can help you today.


To speak with one of our highly knowledgeable attorneys, contact us today at (973)-233-4396 or toll-free at (888)-877-7985. You can also complete the form below to begin your conversation. We are a personalized, boutique-style law firm that offers free initial consultations and flexible appointment options.